Choosing a gas fireplace is no small decision. It’s an investment in comfort, style, and energy efficiency. Two of the biggest names in the industry, Mendota and Fireplace Xtrordinair, both offer premium fireplaces, but each has its strengths.
This guide compares these brands side by side: design, heat output, features, energy efficiency, and costs. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which fireplace is the better fit for your home.
What Are Gas Fireplaces?
Gas fireplaces are a convenient and energy-efficient way to add warmth and ambiance to your home without the hassle of traditional wood-burning fireplaces. They’re powered by natural gas or propane and offer the following perks:
- Clean-burning with no ash or soot
- Easy operation (many include remote control or smart features)
- Sleek, customizable designs
- Consistent heat output
Let’s see how Mendota and Fireplace Xtrordinair stack up.
Mendota vs. Fireplace Xtrordinair: Quick Overview
Mendota
- Known for stunning visuals, customizable aesthetics, and high-end craftsmanship.
- Prioritizes efficiency and advanced heat controls with dual-burner systems.
- Offers one of the most realistic flame presentations in the market.
Fireplace Xtrordinair
- Known for innovative technology and versatility, including fireplaces that fit into smaller spaces or modern layouts.
- Offers GreenSmart® technology for enhanced efficiency and user control.
- Focuses on balancing heat output with design versatility.
Feature Comparison: Mendota vs. Fireplace Xtrordinair
| Feature | Mendota | Fireplace Xtrordinair |
|---|---|---|
| Heat Output (BTU) | 10,000–50,000 (varies by model) | 16,000–60,000 (varies by model) |
| Efficiency Rating | Up to 85% AFUE | Up to 80% AFUE |
| Design Options | Extensive customization (trim, log sets, liners) | Modern, sleek, and traditional designs |
| Smart Features | Simple remote controls | GreenSmart® system with thermostatic controls |
| Realistic Flames | Industry-leading, ultra-realistic flames | Excellent flame technology, slightly less lifelike |
| Warranty | Limited Lifetime Warranty | 7-year Warranty |
| Price Range | $6,000–$10,000+ | $5,000–$9,000+ |
Heat Output and Efficiency
Mendota Heat and Efficiency
Mendota fireplaces are known for their dual-burner technology, which allows you to control flame height and heat output independently. This means you can enjoy a cozy ambiance without overheating your room.
- BTU Range: 10,000–50,000, depending on the model.
- Efficiency: With an AFUE rating of up to 85%, Mendota fireplaces maximize heat while minimizing fuel consumption.
Fireplace Xtrordinair Heat and Efficiency
Fireplace Xtrordinair focuses on powerful heat output and smart efficiency. The GreenSmart® system gives you complete control of the flame, fan, and thermostat to balance comfort and fuel usage.
- BTU Range: 16,000–60,000, ideal for larger spaces.
- Efficiency: AFUE ratings up to 80%.
Aesthetic Design and Customization
Mendota
If you want your fireplace to match your home’s style perfectly, Mendota wins here. From traditional to ultra-modern, Mendota offers:
- Multiple log sets, liners, and trim options
- Realistic flames that look almost indistinguishable from a wood-burning fire
- Slim models for tighter spaces
Fireplace Xtrordinair
Fireplace Xtrordinair is all about versatility. Whether you’re designing a rustic cabin vibe or a sleek contemporary space, they have a model that fits.
- Wide range of sizes, from compact to oversized fireplaces
- Less customization than Mendota but excellent variety in pre-set designs
Smart Features and Technology
Mendota
Mendota keeps it simple with intuitive remote controls for adjusting flames and heat levels. While it doesn’t pack many “smart” features, the two-burner system allows for precise control over both ambiance and warmth.
Fireplace Xtrordinair
This is where Fireplace Xtrordinair shines. The GreenSmart® system comes with advanced features like:
- Thermostat control for consistent room temperature
- Energy-saving pilot ignition systems
- Smart remote that controls flame, fan, and lighting
Safety and Maintenance
Both brands prioritize safety with features like:
- Automatic shut-off timers
- Cool-to-touch exteriors
- Sealed combustion systems for clean indoor air
Maintenance is straightforward for both brands. Regular cleaning of the glass and burner ensures optimal performance. Mendota’s slightly simpler design might edge out Xtrordinair in ease of upkeep.
Price Comparison
Mendota fireplaces are typically more expensive than Fireplace Xtrordinair due to their craftsmanship and lifelike flame technology.
| Model | Mendota Price | Fireplace Xtrordinair Price |
|---|---|---|
| Standard Gas Fireplace | $6,000–$8,000 | $5,000–$7,000 |
| High-Efficiency Model | $8,000–$10,000+ | $7,000–$9,000+ |
Which One Should You Choose?
1. For Lifelike Flames and Customization
- Winner: Mendota
- If aesthetics matter most and you want the most realistic flame experience on the market, Mendota delivers.
2. For Technology and Versatility
- Winner: Fireplace Xtrordinair
- The GreenSmart® system and range of compact and large models make Xtrordinair ideal for tech enthusiasts or unique spaces.
3. For Heating Large Spaces
- Winner: Fireplace Xtrordinair
- With higher BTU outputs, Xtrordinair is better suited for larger rooms or open-plan layouts.
4. For Energy Efficiency
- Winner: Mendota
- Mendota edges out Xtrordinair slightly in efficiency with its higher AFUE ratings.
FAQs
Q: Which brand offers better warranties?
Mendota comes with a Limited Lifetime Warranty, while Fireplace Xtrordinair offers a 7-year warranty.
Q: Are gas fireplaces expensive to run?
Both brands are efficient. The cost depends on your gas rates and usage, but Mendota’s high efficiency can save you more in the long run.
Q: Which brand is easier to install?
Both require professional installation. Fireplace Xtrordinair models are slightly more versatile for unusual layouts.
Final Verdict
Here’s the bottom line:
- Choose Mendota if you want unmatched flame realism, a custom look, and top-tier efficiency.
- Choose Fireplace Xtrordinair if you prioritize technology, flexibility, and heating larger spaces.
Both brands are premium options, so you can’t go wrong—it just depends on your priorities and budget.
